kode adsense disini
Hot Best Seller

Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet

Availability: Ready to download

Look--down there on the ground! It's a guy, he's kinda ordinary...it's--Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack of Doomsday, the mysterious figure claiming to be Clark Kent takes the spotlight to clear his name and prove once and for all that Clark Kent is not Superman! Writer Dan Jurgens (The Death of Superman) continues his return to the Man of Ste Look--down there on the ground! It's a guy, he's kinda ordinary...it's--Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack of Doomsday, the mysterious figure claiming to be Clark Kent takes the spotlight to clear his name and prove once and for all that Clark Kent is not Superman! Writer Dan Jurgens (The Death of Superman) continues his return to the Man of Steel along with illustrators Tyler Kirkham (Deathstroke) and Patrick Zircher (Green Arrow) for the next great Superman chapter in Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet! Collecting: Justice League 52, Action Comics 963-966


Compare
kode adsense disini

Look--down there on the ground! It's a guy, he's kinda ordinary...it's--Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack of Doomsday, the mysterious figure claiming to be Clark Kent takes the spotlight to clear his name and prove once and for all that Clark Kent is not Superman! Writer Dan Jurgens (The Death of Superman) continues his return to the Man of Ste Look--down there on the ground! It's a guy, he's kinda ordinary...it's--Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack of Doomsday, the mysterious figure claiming to be Clark Kent takes the spotlight to clear his name and prove once and for all that Clark Kent is not Superman! Writer Dan Jurgens (The Death of Superman) continues his return to the Man of Steel along with illustrators Tyler Kirkham (Deathstroke) and Patrick Zircher (Green Arrow) for the next great Superman chapter in Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet! Collecting: Justice League 52, Action Comics 963-966

30 review for Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet

  1. 5 out of 5

    Sud666

    The strange new tale of Superman continues in Vol 2. The Superman of this universe is dead, but another Superman from another universe has come to our world. In which there already exists a Clark Kent who is not Superman. Our world remembers Superman but doesn't know that this is another Superman. Lex Luthor is a good guy, sort of, and the "other" Superman has a family and is married to the Lois Lane from the other universe. Did you get all that? Ok then you are on the same frequency as the Afte The strange new tale of Superman continues in Vol 2. The Superman of this universe is dead, but another Superman from another universe has come to our world. In which there already exists a Clark Kent who is not Superman. Our world remembers Superman but doesn't know that this is another Superman. Lex Luthor is a good guy, sort of, and the "other" Superman has a family and is married to the Lois Lane from the other universe. Did you get all that? Ok then you are on the same frequency as the Afterbirth, er sorry..REbirth of DC story arc. Me? I can barely keep track of what version of DC this is since I rarely read comics in order of publishing. Still even with my limited knowledge of rebirth-this was a good story. I may have liked this volume more than the first one. I appreciated the conflict between Superman and Luthor. It is also interesting to see Clark Kent interact with Superman and, must admit, I am curious to see where Dan Jurgens takes this. The artwork is well done and this is an entertaining volume. So far I have to say the Rebirth Action comics has been good. If you are a Superman fan then you will likely enjoy this.

  2. 4 out of 5

    James DeSantis

    I liked the last volume more. I'm a sucker for DBZ level fights throughout various different lands. Watching supes and Doomsday battle it out was great. This volume focuses more on Lois and Clark figuring out what the heck is happening. So we still have two Clarks. Nothing is really answered here. Just the fact this Clark has memories of the Superman Clark but not why he's here, how, or what in general is happening. It's interesting but frustrated. Also we get more into Lois going back into the I liked the last volume more. I'm a sucker for DBZ level fights throughout various different lands. Watching supes and Doomsday battle it out was great. This volume focuses more on Lois and Clark figuring out what the heck is happening. So we still have two Clarks. Nothing is really answered here. Just the fact this Clark has memories of the Superman Clark but not why he's here, how, or what in general is happening. It's interesting but frustrated. Also we get more into Lois going back into the world and living her life. Somewhat interesting. My fave moment in this comic really is with Superman and his son. It's both fun and interesting. I hope to see more of that in the future. Overall not as fun or over the top as volume 1 but still solid. Much better than New52 action comics by fucking MILES.

  3. 5 out of 5

    Roy

    Really dissapointed with this one. I feel like superman is really hit and miss for me. Superman adjusts to the Clark Kent of this world and Lois taking over the old Lois' position at the daily planet. I really felt like nothing happened. Jurgens is way to dialgoue happy which Ive never been a massive fan of.

  4. 5 out of 5

    Chad

    The first half of the book focuses on the new Clark Kent as Superman tries to figure out who he is. He doesn't. In the second half, we find out what happened to new 52 Lois Lane and post-Crisis Lois steps into her place. While the art by Patrick Zircher and Stephen Segovia is very good, I don't find the story interesting at all. Psuedo Clark Kent is written as a dick and keeps spouting the same BS story. Jurgens is not a very good writer and it really shows in this book which is dialogue and plo The first half of the book focuses on the new Clark Kent as Superman tries to figure out who he is. He doesn't. In the second half, we find out what happened to new 52 Lois Lane and post-Crisis Lois steps into her place. While the art by Patrick Zircher and Stephen Segovia is very good, I don't find the story interesting at all. Psuedo Clark Kent is written as a dick and keeps spouting the same BS story. Jurgens is not a very good writer and it really shows in this book which is dialogue and plot heavy. Received an advance copy from DC and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

  5. 4 out of 5

    Danielle

    Read this review and more on my blog, uncovered-books. I received a free copy of Superman: Action Comics Volume 2: Welcome To The Planet from DC Comics in exchange for my honest opinion. This was probably the most fluid volume of comic books that I have ever read. Right from the start, everything made sense and it continued like this until the final panel. After we find out about Lex Luthor becoming the new 'Superman' of Metropolis in the previous volume, we see him in action as 'Superman'. We also Read this review and more on my blog, uncovered-books. I received a free copy of Superman: Action Comics Volume 2: Welcome To The Planet from DC Comics in exchange for my honest opinion. This was probably the most fluid volume of comic books that I have ever read. Right from the start, everything made sense and it continued like this until the final panel. After we find out about Lex Luthor becoming the new 'Superman' of Metropolis in the previous volume, we see him in action as 'Superman'. We also find out how Superman took on the real Clark Kents identity (I am still not convinced that this is true but I will run with it) and Lois returns to The Planet. Since the storyline was so well done, the art style was going to have a hard time keeping up with it, and it almost does. I know that this is my personal preference but I found it to be too line heavy and the colouring to be too blocky for my liking. But honestly they are just minor annoyances that I can live with, and I am sure that their will be some people who will absolutely love how the art work was done. Whilst reading the first volume would benefit you for your understanding reading this volume, it is not completely necessary as the backstory from the previous volume does not confuse you in this volume.

  6. 4 out of 5

    Brendan

    Action packed storyline with Doomsday and everyone is shocked that Clarke Kent is still roaming around. This was a fun collection but the Lex Luthor addition was a little over the top. Hopefully it gets better from here.

  7. 5 out of 5

    Nicola Mansfield

    So I'm getting into this new Superman quite well. Throughout this volume, they pretty much clear up the whole duplicate Supermans, Clark Kents and Lois Lanes. This new Clark Kent who isn't Superman is still a mystery though. I'm not 100% sure how much I *like* this new storyline but it is intriguing and full of mystery. Superwoman makes an appearance and since I haven't read anything about her in Rebirth yet, her identity came as a big shock to me. The book ends with all this being settled for t So I'm getting into this new Superman quite well. Throughout this volume, they pretty much clear up the whole duplicate Supermans, Clark Kents and Lois Lanes. This new Clark Kent who isn't Superman is still a mystery though. I'm not 100% sure how much I *like* this new storyline but it is intriguing and full of mystery. Superwoman makes an appearance and since I haven't read anything about her in Rebirth yet, her identity came as a big shock to me. The book ends with all this being settled for the time being and a new menace makes an appearance. Something quite fresh and intriguing for the Superman.

  8. 5 out of 5

    Jackie

    Slowly but surely, DC Comics is finally fixing their Superman problem.

  9. 4 out of 5

    Douglas Gibson

    I am so confused, but still loving the ride!

  10. 4 out of 5

    Scott S.

    I was confused a chunk of the time, the storyline is still sort of uneven, and nothing was really resolved from vol. 1. That said, the Superman / Lois / Jon scenes were a plus (they are definitely an asset in the superior Superman / Rebirth series) and I still hold out hope that things will get really interesting soon. Have to stay positive, right?

  11. 5 out of 5

    Koen

    Okay, completely different than the previous volume.. And that's a good thing! I liked the battle, but I'm really getting into the story about the Supermen and -women ;) Jurgens has me looking forward to the next one for sure!

  12. 4 out of 5

    Josh

    Not a particularly bad Superman book, just bland. Vanilla ice cream.

  13. 5 out of 5

    Roopkumar Balachandran

    “Look--down there on the ground! It's a guy, he's kinda ordinary...it's--Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack of Doomsday, the mysterious figure claiming to be Clark Kent takes the spotlight to clear his name and prove once and for all that Clark Kent is not Superman!” I have to thank Net galley and DC Entertainment for giving me an opportunity to read this graphic novel. In Volume 2, the story takes place after the epic battle of Superman with Doomsday. Superman is kil “Look--down there on the ground! It's a guy, he's kinda ordinary...it's--Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack of Doomsday, the mysterious figure claiming to be Clark Kent takes the spotlight to clear his name and prove once and for all that Clark Kent is not Superman!” I have to thank Net galley and DC Entertainment for giving me an opportunity to read this graphic novel. In Volume 2, the story takes place after the epic battle of Superman with Doomsday. Superman is killed, before that the world comes to know that Clark Kent and Superman are same person. Now Clark Kent with fractured left hand comes to Daily Planet to finish his investigation on Geneticron, later Clark was thrown out of the building and Superman! saves him. Both know they are not who they are. Superman takes Clark to Fortress of Solitude and tests him, the result was unexpected and the mystery deepens. Superman is seen married to Lois and having a kid named Jon, trying their best to adapt to their new world. This graphic novel revolves around the lives of Clark Kent and Lois Lane. Lois been dead! and another Lois taking her place and trying to finish the book on Superman. The story is not conclusive but it has its fair share of mystery and twists which will surely engage us. The art work is good, written by Dan Jurgens and pencils by Tom Grummett for That which you manifest is before you, Patch Zircher for Superman meets Clark Kent Part I & II, Stephen Segovia in Lois Lane Back at the Planet Part I & II.

  14. 4 out of 5

    Wayne McCoy

    'Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet' by Dan Jurgens will make you feel really confused if you haven't read Superman for a while, but come on in. The water is fine. Superman is dead. Clark Kent is alive. Lex Luthor is Superman now. Also, there is a new Superman who is married to Lois Lane and has a son named Jon. That's just the beginning. The new Superman wants to check out Clark Kent to make sure he isn't Superman in hiding. Lex Luthor really wants Superman's cape so he get 'Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet' by Dan Jurgens will make you feel really confused if you haven't read Superman for a while, but come on in. The water is fine. Superman is dead. Clark Kent is alive. Lex Luthor is Superman now. Also, there is a new Superman who is married to Lois Lane and has a son named Jon. That's just the beginning. The new Superman wants to check out Clark Kent to make sure he isn't Superman in hiding. Lex Luthor really wants Superman's cape so he gets it the way only the super wealthy can. The new Lois Lane is on a mission from this world's counterpart to finish a book on the life and death of Superman. Did I mention that there is a SuperWoman too? This collects Justice League 52 and Action Comics 963-966. It tells a pretty interesting story and sets things up for future stories fairly well. It will be interesting to see how Superman, Clark Kent, and Lex Luthor all play things out, and how Lana Lang fits into everything. This volume has pretty decent art. There is also a cover gallery with some pretty striking covers. I like the one featuring alternating ribbons showing Superman and Clark Kent. There are also some pencil breakdowns for some covers and splash pages. I received a review copy of this graphic novel from DC Entertainment and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.

  15. 4 out of 5

    Shannon Appelcline

    A nice character-driven book that almost totally reverses course from the excesses of fighting in the previous volume. Instead, three different short stories ask three great questions about the interesting Rebirth status quo: how did Lex get the cape? who is Clark Kent? and what is Lois' role going forward? With its wide breadth, this volume of Action Comics loses a lot of the family dynamic that was so enjoyable in Jurgens' Lois & Clark, but nonetheless he does a great way of pushing forward A nice character-driven book that almost totally reverses course from the excesses of fighting in the previous volume. Instead, three different short stories ask three great questions about the interesting Rebirth status quo: how did Lex get the cape? who is Clark Kent? and what is Lois' role going forward? With its wide breadth, this volume of Action Comics loses a lot of the family dynamic that was so enjoyable in Jurgens' Lois & Clark, but nonetheless he does a great way of pushing forward the narrative in an interesting way and continuing to integrate Superdad into the nuDC universe.

  16. 5 out of 5

    Christian Zamora-Dahmen

    This second volume was way better than the first. Putting aside the neverending battles and focusing on Clark Kent's mystery and Lois Lane's next move was a step into the right direction. This is the Dan Jurgens that I like and enjoy so much reading. It didn't get a solid 5-star because his Jon is a bit off when compared to the one portrayed in the Superman book.

  17. 5 out of 5

    Daniel Butcher

    4.5. Fun, enjoyable, just a little more payoff needed. Part of me feels like they are arranging to everyone's preferred state of Superman by Action 1000.

  18. 4 out of 5

    Emmett Spain

    A good volume, but not hugely memorable for me, except for the distinction of having a couple of Lois-centric issues at the end. I’m definitely pleased with how Superman is written, though. Rebirth has already exceeded the New 52 for me.

  19. 5 out of 5

    Stabbing

    Read as single issue comics. Better than volume one.

  20. 5 out of 5

    Adam Graham

    This book is a bit of a challenge for trade readers. Comics these days are often "written for the trades" so that each block of six or seven issues fits nicely into a trade paperback as an epic storyline. This one doesn't. We get Issue 52 of the New 52 Justice league combined with Issues 963-966 of Action Comics. You don't get any resolution from any of this. Questions are explored but nothing's resolved, but you at least feel the stories are going somewhere. The book kicks off with, "That Which This book is a bit of a challenge for trade readers. Comics these days are often "written for the trades" so that each block of six or seven issues fits nicely into a trade paperback as an epic storyline. This one doesn't. We get Issue 52 of the New 52 Justice league combined with Issues 963-966 of Action Comics. You don't get any resolution from any of this. Questions are explored but nothing's resolved, but you at least feel the stories are going somewhere. The book kicks off with, "That Which You Manifest is Before You" which is a Lex Luthor story of how he's returned to Earth even though he could rule Apokolips and wants the cape of the new 52 Superman, who was killed off. It's a story of how he bought the Daily Planet and began to identify as Superman. More important than that, it's why he'd choose to do that rather than being a cosmic force. The answer is very humanizing and it shows how Dan Jurgens take on Luthor is very different than others. This is a particularly interesting story for those of us who didn't follow the New 52 as we wondered what Luthor's intentions were in trying to become Superman. Here we see that they are honorable and noble and that he's trying to be a better person. It doesn't mean that he'll succeed or that his old instincts won't betray him, but it's good set up. Next up is Meet Clark Kent, a two part story where Superman tries to find out the truth about the Clark Kent that re-appeared during his duel with Doomsday in the previous volume. He doesn't really achieve it. He finds out a lot about who this Clark Kent isn't but next to nothing about who he is. We're merely dipping our toe into this mystery. It does end with Clark writing a very nice article on Superman. Finally, we have Back at the Planet, where Lois tries to find out what happened to the New 52 version of herself by going undercover at the Planet. Again, we don't learn conclusively what actually happened to the New 52 Lois but we do meet Superwoman and get a hint of what may have happened. We also get to see Lois return to work with all the problems of pretending to be a younger alternate universe version of yourself that's ten years younger glossed over. We're treated to "Girl power" proclamations about why a mother of a ten year old can return to work which is very culturally relevant in a 21st Century world where Women frequently return to work when their children are three months old. The story just feels forced. I'm not sure whether it was an editorial mandate or just a status quo of Lois working at the Planet that Jurgens wanted to restore, but it's a weak tale right from the psychic message that sent our Lois to the planet right to the over the top over exuberant argument for her returning from work that would have made sense in the 1980s. But still we do get more interesting questions to be explored in later volumes, but the weaknesses of the final story do drag the volume down a bit.

  21. 4 out of 5

    Will Robinson Jr.

    I am going to warn all readers you must read Superman: Lois and Clark, Superman: The Final Days of Superman, Superman: Action Comics, Volume 1: Path of Doom& maybe DC Universe: Rebirth #1 to get a clear picture at the direction this volume is going. I hope this will not intimidate new readers from jumping into this volume of Action comics. Dan Jurgens does a great job of catching readers up on what has happened proceeding this volume. I felt that the inclusion of Lex Luther's self imposed ta I am going to warn all readers you must read Superman: Lois and Clark, Superman: The Final Days of Superman, Superman: Action Comics, Volume 1: Path of Doom& maybe DC Universe: Rebirth #1 to get a clear picture at the direction this volume is going. I hope this will not intimidate new readers from jumping into this volume of Action comics. Dan Jurgens does a great job of catching readers up on what has happened proceeding this volume. I felt that the inclusion of Lex Luther's self imposed taking the mantle of Superman was a special bonus to the narrative in the book. It was great to see that the events that Lex experience on Apokolips are still canon. Readers may want to check out Justice League: The Darkseid War Saga Omnibus when it comes out or pick up Justice League, Volume 7: Darkseid War, Part 1 & Justice League, Volume 8: Darkseid War, Part 2. The mention books were written by Geoff Johns and they were awesome. In Superman: Action Comics, Volume 2: Welcome to the Planet we find our new "Superman" aka Clark, Lois, & their son Jon trying to adjust to life since a recent Doomsday attack on Metropolis. The story transitions into a mystery as both Lex Luther and Clark are trying to discover the true identity of the all human Clark Kent. Over the course of the book things get interesting as Lois finds herself at the Daily Planet impersonating her doppelganger. I mean this story is a real mind-bender. You have two Clark Kents, Two Lois Lanes, a dead Superman and Lex is Superman. It is so funny trying to explain this tale. But the artwork is great and the book is really entertaining. I still feel like the Peter Tomasi Superman series is better but Jurgens is still having fun with the character. I am looking forward to the next volume.

  22. 4 out of 5

    Wing Kee

    I'm torn. World: The art is fine, the art has a retro quality to it that I both enjoy but also don't like, as I said, I'm torn. The colors are also flat in some cases but stunning in others (Superwoman comes to mind). The world building is still fairly interesting and intriguing. With the changed status quo of Lex as Superman, Human Clark and DCU Lois and Clark the dynamic is good and the mystery is something I enjoying, even if it's a bit tacky at the same time. Story: The human Clark issues we I'm torn. World: The art is fine, the art has a retro quality to it that I both enjoy but also don't like, as I said, I'm torn. The colors are also flat in some cases but stunning in others (Superwoman comes to mind). The world building is still fairly interesting and intriguing. With the changed status quo of Lex as Superman, Human Clark and DCU Lois and Clark the dynamic is good and the mystery is something I enjoying, even if it's a bit tacky at the same time. Story: The human Clark issues were a but choppy but the Lois issues were emotional and well done. I want to avoid spoilers but I am still awfully torn on what they did with New52 Lois, just like I was torn with New52 Supes. I kinda understand they path they went because they needed to set a new status quo, but at the same time I'm not completely okay with how DC 'honored her'. The mystery of these characters is intriguing and I am enjoying the story so far. Characters: A but choppy and janky this arc and being of my torn feelings on how they are dealing and dealt with New52 Lois I was torn in this area. Clark is classic Clark and human Clark is a mystery which I am enjoying. Pretty much all the characters I am enjoying simply because I don't know where DC will go with them. Strong but still a mystery. Torn but still a good mystery. Onward to the next book!

  23. 4 out of 5

    Fahim Ahmed

    The Clark story was good. Loved the Lois story, and at this point it just goes without saying that writer Dan Jurgens simply 'gets' these characters. The art is decent enough, though I highly prefer Superman's art. Action Comics may be lesser Supes book, having said that the character has never been in a better place for the 5 years that I've been reading comics. Hey at least it's better than Batman that's getting slayed by Detective week in and week out.

  24. 5 out of 5

    Norman Cook

    The mystery deepens of how Superman and Clark Kent can be separate people. Meanwhile, Superman, Lois, and their son, Jon, continue their efforts to adjust to their new world. I got the sense that all this is mostly a set-up for better character development and action to come. Not horrible, by any means, but not really that exciting, either. Note: I read this as individual comic book issues.

  25. 4 out of 5

    Emmanuel Nevers

    Way better than volume in my opinion. This one gives you a bunch of smaller story arcs dealing with how Superman and Lois are adapting to the rebirth/new 52 continuity. I loved it!

  26. 4 out of 5

    Lestat

    I am always stunned when I get comic books by the Big 2 off Netgalley; now I'm beginning to think this is not a compliment but an insult. I don't know where to start with this volume. I'm not an avid follower of comics, and timelines, storylines and general chronology escapes me. Despite this being the second part to Superman: Action Comics, Volume 1: Path of Doom, I still haven't understood the central premise of Superman leaving Earth with his family to set up shop on a parallel Earth. I know I I am always stunned when I get comic books by the Big 2 off Netgalley; now I'm beginning to think this is not a compliment but an insult. I don't know where to start with this volume. I'm not an avid follower of comics, and timelines, storylines and general chronology escapes me. Despite this being the second part to Superman: Action Comics, Volume 1: Path of Doom, I still haven't understood the central premise of Superman leaving Earth with his family to set up shop on a parallel Earth. I know I'm missing something, but none of the stories excite me enough to bother digging around for more. This particular volume must have seemed like a good idea to the writers and editors - it is essentially 100-odd pages of world-building. But even then it lacks the ability to stretch its imagination to include said world. We discover precious little about New Earth (I'm going to call it that) and instead must follow the daily goings-on at the Kent household. Parallel to this, is New Earth's Clark Kent's investigation of what killed their Superman, which has something to do with Lex Luthor, the new Superman. Yes, it is all exactly as confusing as that. As the story meanders along, we are thrust into some family 'drama'. Lois wants her life back - she's had to give it up all these years to stay home and take of the Kent scion, but now she's found a way to do what she loves best - be a reporter at the Daily Planet on New Earth. We harp on about this difficult decision for several pages, because, even in the 21st Century, the writers of Superman comics cannot envision a scenario where Superman and Lois Lane split family duties, giving up neither of their lives in the bargain, but compromising gratefully for each other. I think there are more working class families in real life splitting domestic duties better than the greatest superhero in comic book history. Excuse me while I break something. I feel the writers were hoping to capture the guilt of a working mother, but the dialogue came across as simpering and pedantic; encapsulating none of the true feelings many women have spoken about (the writers could have done a simple google search), instead writing the entire episode from a patriarchal viewpoint. Given this is DC, the comic is primarily white - I don't mean the art, I mean the people. There is no diversity in ethnicity, race, sexuality, ability or body type; and next to no women of note barring Lois. It's an eye-sore. It gets so bad, there's a page of panels featuring a crowd of only white, mostly male figures. I... don't get it. One positive is the book's art. While it isn't imaginative or creative, it is vivid and vibrant; an absolute pleasure to look at. We now move onto some spoilers: This volume introduces us to Superwoman, who informs Lois and Superman that Lois Lane of New Earth is dead; killed in front of her. Lois has conveniently kept a recording ready for Lois (try and keep up) asking her to continue in her stead at the Daily Planet. If we did a survey of actual people, I would like to see just how many receive videos from the recently deceased. It must be a popular method, because in 2017 itself I have come across three different media in which videos from the dead have helped the living move on (TV's Sherlock, The Summer of Impossible Things and now this one). Creepily Lois takes on the task of stepping into Lois' shoes and taking over her job. BTW, New Earth's Lois was a Superwoman - one of two, as it were, till she died from her newfound powers. Convenient. None of the mysteries are wrapped up in this volume, and that frustrated me no end. New Earth's Clark's investigation goes nowhere, Lois' death is not solved, Lex' underhandedness is not discovered. For that, we must get another comic book. Rolls eyes. End of spoilers. The volume doesn't bother to answer any of the questions it poses, neither does it move the story along in any form. One wonders why Superman even came here, because it is evident he did no research or reconnaissance before planting himself here. His life is so bizarre that he can't even meet his son's friend for fear of being recognised. Where is this story going, and what is the point of this mirror planet - the writers are stringing us along hoping we'll keep buying their comics to find out. But I don't care. These characters, this writing, the story isn't gripping enough to bother about.

  27. 5 out of 5

    Robert

    This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. This gets the 1 star award of "I got too bored and started skimming." The dialogue is just absolutely terrible. I forgot to write it down, but there's a line from Perry White to Lex Luthor that sounds like it was right out of a 1950s sitcom. No one in 21st century talks that way! Especially not editors at major newspapers. Between the unnaturalness and the blatant exposition, the dialogue seems like it would be entirely too at home in the campy, Adam West Batman show. Then there's the plot contriv This gets the 1 star award of "I got too bored and started skimming." The dialogue is just absolutely terrible. I forgot to write it down, but there's a line from Perry White to Lex Luthor that sounds like it was right out of a 1950s sitcom. No one in 21st century talks that way! Especially not editors at major newspapers. Between the unnaturalness and the blatant exposition, the dialogue seems like it would be entirely too at home in the campy, Adam West Batman show. Then there's the plot contrivances. I'm not entirely sure where this 100% human Clark Kent storyline is going, but right now I'm willing to bet that it's setting up for exactly what happened to New 52 Lois Lane: establishing the old status quo. Jurgens and DC killing off New 52 Lois Lane and then having her send a completely out of character plea to the new Lois Lane to please pretend to be her and take over her old life is absolutely absurd. The whole characterization of Lois is just terrible. Lois was an ambitious, driven journalist who risked life and limb to get a story back in the pre-Flashpoint DC universe, but as soon as she has a kid and ends up in a parallel universe, she's willing to be a stay-at-home-mom who anonymously writes big exposé books in her spare time? Huh? I don't buy it. But even if I did, if you're now willing to tell me that that same woman, after doing that for a decade (how old is John?) now feels the burning need to work at a major newspaper again so badly that she's willing to try to impersonate her alternate universe doppelganger? What? I suppose there are plenty of driven women who put their careers on hold to raise their kids, but I just don't know if Lois Lane is that kind of woman. The right writer could probably pull it off, but Dan Jurgens isn't that writer. Instead, it just comes off as a series of awkward contrivances blatantly designed to get the pre-Flashpoint status quo of Clark and Lois into the New 52 universe. So, at the end of all of this, here's what I'm expecting: human-Clark will finally establish to everyone that he's not and never has been Superman. Then he'll die and the pre-Flashpoint Clark and take over his life (just like Lois took over New 52-Lois's life) and go back to being a reporter for the Daily Planet. There will be some ridiculous explanation for what brought human-Clark into existence and then poof he'll be gone. And can we just talk about how absurd this whole human-Clark is, beyond the mere fact of his existence? Who Clark Kent, the disguise, was as a person was a combination of two things: who Clark Kent really was (a superhuman growing up in humble Smalltown, USA) combined with that man's desire to be unassuming. Clark's public persona wouldn't be who it was if he'd grown up as who he pretended to be. Worse still, that persona, the "mild mannered reporter" (which he literally refers to himself as!) would not break into a building and risk death to get a story. Real Clark might, because he can't get hurt. But the Clark persona that everyone at the Daily Planet knows him as? I don't think so. If he would, then that persona wouldn't be a "mild mannered report," it'd be a daredevil reporter just like Lois Lane. Finally, apparently glowing (or being on fire?) is enough to make Lana Lang completely unrecognizable? How is it that we, the readers, can clearly tell who she is but Superman and Lois Lane need her to turn her super-flames off in order to not just recognize her but to immediately recognize her? Ugh. This book was just a nonstop exercise in annoyance. The kind of poorly-written schlock that makes me wonder why I bother reading all these comics in the first place. At least Superman, Volume 2: Trial of the Super Sons was good.

  28. 5 out of 5

    SSShafiq

    These stories are the promised wrap-up on a number of story threads which were introduced in the Superman: The Final Days of Superman, Superman: Lois and Clark, and Volume 1. A working knowledge of these volumes is recommended otherwise nothing in this will make much sense. Most of the comics deal with the new Super-people and Clark Kent. It felt like a transition volume where we leave the New 52 behind and head into Rebirth full steam ahead. Some of the New 52 pieces get left behind and the Re These stories are the promised wrap-up on a number of story threads which were introduced in the Superman: The Final Days of Superman, Superman: Lois and Clark, and Volume 1. A working knowledge of these volumes is recommended otherwise nothing in this will make much sense. Most of the comics deal with the new Super-people and Clark Kent. It felt like a transition volume where we leave the New 52 behind and head into Rebirth full steam ahead. Some of the New 52 pieces get left behind and the Rebirth characters take centre stage. (view spoiler)[For example, New 52 Lois dies and Rebirth Lois takes ‘her’ job back at the Daily Planet. (hide spoiler)] I liked this volume a lot more than the previous volume. It was generally easy to follow and though no big battles happen, I liked the change in pace. The mystery of the human Clark Kent was interesting and one I am intrigued about. I did feel that his introduction is more to allow Superman to step back into the role of Clark Kent (once they inevitably kill the human Clark) than a real mystery. Superwoman Lois functions like that as well. I can see the chess pawns being moved into place so I was not particularly surprised or emotionally invested. It all felt a little too convenient. Super-Lex was the weakest part for me but I am sure he gets more development in the next volume. His obsession with becoming Superman didn't really come across as convincing and I had been following his fall to the Light Side from the new 52 run. The best parts remain the new Super-family: Lois, Clark and Jon. It was nice to see Lois get more screen time and the acknowledgement that she had lost her life and career as well. She was always the more dedicated reporter of the couple and it was nice to see Superman acknowledge that “it’s time [they] focus on [her].” Overall, this volume is recommended and improves upon Volume 1.

  29. 5 out of 5

    Rolando Marono

    Mejoró muchísimo la historia y la calidad de los diálogos del volumen anterior a este. No tenía muchas ganas de continuar con esta historia (aún cuando Lex Luthor Supes me seguía llamando la atención), tardé mucho en comprar el segundo y tardé un poco en leerlo. Pero me sorprendió gratamente. Entiendo que los tipos de historia vistos en el volumen uno y en este, son radicalmente opuestos. Uno está plagado de acción y peleas y este es puro diálogo, misterio e investigación, porque ni siquiera apar Mejoró muchísimo la historia y la calidad de los diálogos del volumen anterior a este. No tenía muchas ganas de continuar con esta historia (aún cuando Lex Luthor Supes me seguía llamando la atención), tardé mucho en comprar el segundo y tardé un poco en leerlo. Pero me sorprendió gratamente. Entiendo que los tipos de historia vistos en el volumen uno y en este, son radicalmente opuestos. Uno está plagado de acción y peleas y este es puro diálogo, misterio e investigación, porque ni siquiera aparece un villano. A mí me gusta más este estilo de historia, y aunque podría parecer raro que en una historia de súper héroes, y más si es una de Superman, no hubiese peleas ni villanos. Pero si contrastas lo sucedido en el primer volumen, y lees de corrido los dos, sentirás un buen balance: 5 números de acción contra doomsday y 5 números de diálogos, investigación y misterio. Me gustó mucho el número con el que abre el volumen, donde protagoniza Lex Luthor. Este número aprovecha para responder misterios y cuestionamientos de lo visto en el volumen anterior. Aquí nos muestran el regreso de Luthor, y su primer encuentro con las personas del Planet, además que nos explican, a través de narraciones en primera persona, de por qué decidió volverse Superman. El resto de la historia está lleno de dobles versiones de la misma persona (como lo vimos en el primer volumen y que fue muy confuso) aquí se empiezan a aclarar las cosas pero no tenemos conclusiones respecto a por qué hay dos Clark Kents. Hay mucho desarrollo de personajes en el volumen, porque vemos también que le pasó a Lois New 52, a Lana, a la Lois nueva, etc. Pero muchas de las preguntas son contestadas a medias y eso no me gustó del todo. Se empiezan a mostrar pistas para una historia siguiente, me parece interesante. Además el nuevo status de Lana y la amenaza biológica que se cierne sobre ellos, parece ser que nos dará un tercer volumen balanceado.

  30. 4 out of 5

    Sarah

    This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. Don't let the four stars fool you--I really enjoyed this graphic novel. But the other three Superman and Action Comic Rebirth graphic novels I've read I enjoyed so exponentially much that, in comparison, this is one star less. No particular reason, besides I'm not sure how I feel about the whole (*spoiler*) Lana Lang as Superwoman thing. I'm okay with them killing off New 52 Lois Lane, though--mostly because she was infuriating (I mean, seriously, who outs Clark Kent as Superman?!?!?!), and also Don't let the four stars fool you--I really enjoyed this graphic novel. But the other three Superman and Action Comic Rebirth graphic novels I've read I enjoyed so exponentially much that, in comparison, this is one star less. No particular reason, besides I'm not sure how I feel about the whole (*spoiler*) Lana Lang as Superwoman thing. I'm okay with them killing off New 52 Lois Lane, though--mostly because she was infuriating (I mean, seriously, who outs Clark Kent as Superman?!?!?!), and also because that's a nice way for the REAL Lois we know and love to come back to the Daily Planet--with some nice added conflict of her, technically, not being the same Lois her co-workers and friends knew. But still, I loved the moments with Jon (particularly the scene when he and his dad raced--and he won!). There's such a wonderful innocence that comes with his character that I haven't seen in any other comics except some Captain Marvel stories, such as "Superman/Shazam: First Thunder." (A wonderful read that I would highly recommend, by the way). I'm also intrigued by both Lex Luthor's (seemingly) redemptive story arc and by this mysterious other Clark Kent. I was hoping to get some answers to the latter in this volume, and when I didn't, I was kind of bummed. But it's definitely a nice mystery, and I'm eager to keep reading to find out more about him, Luthor, and lives of the "Smith" family.

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Loading...
We use cookies to give you the best online experience. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our cookie policy.